The Pizza Man (Lyndonville, VT)

Pizza Man

663 Broad St.
Lyndonville, VT 05851

Presentation = 4.6
Taste = 4.1
Eatability = 2.5 (TMJ)
Bread = 3.7 (untoasted but still crunchy)
Sauce = 3.8 (chunky)
Cheese = 2.0 (not melted)

Price: $8.99

OVERALL = 20.7

Mighty Subs

Mighty Subs

250 Highland Ave.
Needham, MA 02494

*The size has so much to do with these scores. I was impressed, but scared.

Presentation = 5.0
Taste = 4.6
Eatability = 2.8
Bread = 4.4
Sauce = 4.1
Cheese = 4.7

Price: $10.49

OVERALL = 25.6

Tom's Pizza

Tom's Pizza

423 Lexington St.
Newton, MA 02466

Presentation = 3.7
Taste = 4.5
Eatability = 4.1
Bread = 4.8
Sauce = 4.6
Cheese = 3.2

Price: $7.60

OVERALL = 24.9

Vello's

Vello's

679 High St.
Westwood, MA 02090

Presentation = 4.1
Taste = 4.8
Eatability = 5.0
Bread = 4.3
Sauce = 4.6
Cheese = 4.0

Price: $9.99

OVERALL = 26.8

Moogy's

Moogy's

154 Chestnut Hill Ave.
Brighton, MA 02135

Presentation = 3.4
Taste = 4.6
Eatability = 4.5
Bread = 4.2
Sauce = 4.4
Cheese = 4.1

Price: $9.00

OVERALL = 25.2

Guest appearance! Johnny's Steaks (Jersey Shore/AC)

Johnny's (Margate, NJ)

9403 Ventnor Ave.
Margate City, NJ 08042

First and best true Philly Cheese Steak.

Split two with Moose and Chappy.

OVERALL = A+

Pino's (Cleveland Circle)

Pino's Pizza

1920-A  Beacon St.
Brighton, MA 02135

Presentation = 4.1
Taste = 4.9
Eatability = 4.4
Bread = 3.7
Sauce = 3.8
Cheese = 5.0

Price: $7.00

OVERALL = 25.9

Italian Groceria (Medfield)

Italian Groceria

258 Main St.
Medfield, MA 02052

Presentation = 4.3
Taste = 4.8
Eatability = 3.9
Bread = 4.5
Sauce = 4.1
Cheese = 4.7

Price: $8.25

OVERALL = 26.3

High St. Market (Westwood)

High St. Market

687 High St.
Westwood, MA 02090

Presentation = 3.7
Taste = 4.1
Eatability = 4.7
Bread = 4.4
Sauce = 3.6
Cheese = 2.7

Price: $6.95

OVERALL = 23.2

Wellesley House of Pizza

WHOP

19 Washington St.
Wellesley, MA 02481

Presentation = 3.8
Taste = 4.6
Eatability = 3.1 
Bread = 3.6
Sauce = 4.2
Cheese = 4.0

Price: $7.75

OVERALL = 23.3

Eddie's Variety (Portland, ME)

Eddie's

*Portland North Little League District Champs 1994*

377 Auburn St.
Portland, ME 04103

Presentation = 4.2
Taste = 4.6
Eatability = 4.2
Bread = 4.1
Sauce = 3.9
Cheese = 4.4

Price: $5.95

OVERALL = 25.4

Islington Pizza

Islington House of Pizza

315 Washington St.

Westwood, MA 02090

Presentation = 4.4
Taste = 4.8
Eatability = 4.8
Bread = 4.3
Sauce = 4.2
Cheese = 4.0

Price: $7.59

OVERALL = 26.5

Guest appearance! Mother's (New Orleans, LA)

Mother's Restaurant (New Orleans)

401 Poydras St

New Orleans, LA 70130

Presentation = 3.9
Taste = 4.8
Eatability = 4.6
Bread = 4.4
Sauce = n/a
Cheese = n/a

Price: $13.00

OVERALL = A+

Bonne Chance

Bonne Chance

77 Canal St.

Boston, MA 02114

Presentation = 2.6
Taste = 3.1
Eatability = 2.7
Bread = 4.2
Sauce = 3.2
Cheese = 3.6

Price: $6.99

OVERALL = 19.4

Di Matteo's Pizza

Di Matteo's Pizza (Hamden, CT)

2100 Dixwell Ave.

Hamden, CT 06514

Presentation = 3.8
Taste = 3.1
Eatability = 2.2
Bread = 4.4
Sauce = 2.9
Cheese = 3.8

Price: $7.20

OVERALL = 20.2

Jake n Joe's (Norwood)

Jake n Joe's (Norwood)

475 Providence Hwy

Norwood, MA 02062

Presentation = 4.7
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 3.8
Bread = 4.2
Sauce = 4.3
Cheese = 3.2

Price: $12.50

OVERALL = 24.4

Comella's

Comella's (Westwood)

745 High St.

Westwood, MA 02090

Presentation = 4.8
Taste = 4.7
Eatability = 4.5
Bread = 4.7
Sauce = 4.3
Cheese = 4.0

Price: $6.49

OVERALL = 27.0

Stella's

Stella's Pizza

605 Mt. Auburn St.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 4.1
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 4.6
Bread = 4.3
Sauce = 3.7
Cheese = 3.9

Price: $6.50

OVERALL = 24.8

T Anthony's

T Anthony's Pizzeria

1016 Commonwealth Ave.

Boston, MA 02215

Presentation = 4.6
Taste = 4.8
Eatability = 4.1
Bread = 4.2
Sauce = 4.4
Cheese = 4.7

Price: $7.90

OVERALL = 26.8

Nicholas' Pizzeria

Nicholas' Pizzeria

33 Chapel St.

Needham, MA 02492

Presentation = 2.9
Taste = 4.1
Eatability = 2.4
Bread = 4.1
Sauce = 3.1
Cheese = 3.6

Price: $7.49

OVERALL = 20.2

Pizza Roma

Pizza Roma

212 Waverley Ave.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 3.8
Taste = 4.5
Eatability = 4.4
Bread = 3.8
Sauce = 3.7
Cheese = 3.7

Price: $6.99

OVERALL = 23.9

Ike's Place (CA)

Ike's Place

680 E 3rd Ave.

San Mateo, CA 94401

Presentation = 4.0
Taste = 3.7
Eatability = 5.0
Bread = 4.4
Sauce = 3.1
Cheese = 2.7

Price: $7.97

OVERALL = 22.9

Milton House of Pizza

Milton House of Pizza

537 Adams St.

Milton, MA 02186

Presentation = 3.6
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 4.5
Bread = 4.6
Sauce = 3.4
Cheese = 3.8

Price: $6.99

OVERALL = 24.1

Boston House of Pizza (Watertown)

Boston House of Pizza

115 Galen St.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 4.0
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 3.8
Bread = 2.7
Sauce = 4.3
Cheese = 3.9

Price: $7.99

OVERALL = 22.9

Pleasent St. Pizza

Pleasant Pizza & Subs

467 Pleasant St.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 3.7
Taste = 4.4
Eatability = 4.9
Bread = 2.1
Sauce = 3.4
Cheese = 4.1

Price: $5.95

OVERALL = 22.6