Jake n Joe's (Norwood)

Jake n Joe's (Norwood)

475 Providence Hwy

Norwood, MA 02062

Presentation = 4.7
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 3.8
Bread = 4.2
Sauce = 4.3
Cheese = 3.2

Price: $12.50

OVERALL = 24.4

Comella's

Comella's (Westwood)

745 High St.

Westwood, MA 02090

Presentation = 4.8
Taste = 4.7
Eatability = 4.5
Bread = 4.7
Sauce = 4.3
Cheese = 4.0

Price: $6.49

OVERALL = 27.0

Stella's

Stella's Pizza

605 Mt. Auburn St.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 4.1
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 4.6
Bread = 4.3
Sauce = 3.7
Cheese = 3.9

Price: $6.50

OVERALL = 24.8

T Anthony's

T Anthony's Pizzeria

1016 Commonwealth Ave.

Boston, MA 02215

Presentation = 4.6
Taste = 4.8
Eatability = 4.1
Bread = 4.2
Sauce = 4.4
Cheese = 4.7

Price: $7.90

OVERALL = 26.8

Nicholas' Pizzeria

Nicholas' Pizzeria

33 Chapel St.

Needham, MA 02492

Presentation = 2.9
Taste = 4.1
Eatability = 2.4
Bread = 4.1
Sauce = 3.1
Cheese = 3.6

Price: $7.49

OVERALL = 20.2

Pizza Roma

Pizza Roma

212 Waverley Ave.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 3.8
Taste = 4.5
Eatability = 4.4
Bread = 3.8
Sauce = 3.7
Cheese = 3.7

Price: $6.99

OVERALL = 23.9

Ike's Place (CA)

Ike's Place

680 E 3rd Ave.

San Mateo, CA 94401

Presentation = 4.0
Taste = 3.7
Eatability = 5.0
Bread = 4.4
Sauce = 3.1
Cheese = 2.7

Price: $7.97

OVERALL = 22.9

Milton House of Pizza

Milton House of Pizza

537 Adams St.

Milton, MA 02186

Presentation = 3.6
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 4.5
Bread = 4.6
Sauce = 3.4
Cheese = 3.8

Price: $6.99

OVERALL = 24.1

Boston House of Pizza (Watertown)

Boston House of Pizza

115 Galen St.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 4.0
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 3.8
Bread = 2.7
Sauce = 4.3
Cheese = 3.9

Price: $7.99

OVERALL = 22.9

Pleasent St. Pizza

Pleasant Pizza & Subs

467 Pleasant St.

Watertown, MA 02472

Presentation = 3.7
Taste = 4.4
Eatability = 4.9
Bread = 2.1
Sauce = 3.4
Cheese = 4.1

Price: $5.95

OVERALL = 22.6

Shorty's (NYC)

Shorty's

576 9th Ave.

New York, NY 10036

Presentation = 4.4
Taste = 5.0
Eatability = 4.8
Bread = 4.9
Sauce = 4.7
Cheese = 4.8

Price: $11.00

OVERALL = 28.6

Sbarro (NYC)

Sbarro, Times Square

1606 Broadway #897

New York, NY 10019

Presentation = 3.4
Taste = 3.7
Eatability = 4.0
Bread = 2.6
Sauce = 4.1
Cheese = 2.1

Price: $7.50

OVERALL = 19.9

54 Gourmet (NYC)

54 Gourmet

250 W 54th St.

New York, NY 10019

Presentation = 2.7
Taste = 3.4
Eatability = 3.1
Bread = 3.8
Sauce = 3.3
Cheese = 4.6

Price: $6.95

OVERALL = 20.9

Village Hero (NY)

Village Heros

80 Jericho Turnpike

Syosset, NY 11791

Presentation = 3.2
Taste = 4.7
Eatability = 1.8
Bread = 4.9
Sauce = 4.2
Cheese = 4.5

Price: $10.99

OVERALL = 23.3

Bova's Bakery

Bova's Bakery

134 Salem St.

Boston, MA 02113

Presentation = 3.2
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 5.0
Bread = 4.8
Sauce = 4.1
Cheese = 4.0

Price: $5.99

OVERALL = 25.3

Causeway Cafe

Causeway Cafe

239 Causeway St.

Boston, MA 02114

Presentation = 3.6
Taste = 3.2
Eatability = 4.4
Bread = 3.7
Sauce = 3.9
Cheese = 3.1

Price: $8.50

OVERALL = 21.9

Sal's Lunch

Sal's Lunch (North End)

31 Thacher St.

Boston, MA 02113

Presentation = 2.1
Taste = 1.5
Eatability = 3.5
Bread = 4.1
Sauce = 1.9
Cheese = 1.1

Price: $6.99

OVERALL = 14.2

Pauli's

Pauli's (North End)

65 Salem St.

Boston, MA 02113

Presentation = 4.3
Taste = 4.4
Eatability = 3.8
Bread = 5.0
Sauce = 4.6
Cheese = 4.1

Price: $6.99

OVERALL = 26.2

Halftime Pizza

Halftime Pizza

115 Causeway St.

Boston, MA 02114

Presentation = 4.5
Taste = 4.2
Eatability = 4.8
Bread = 4.7
Sauce = 2.9
Cheese = 4.1

Price: $7.25

OVERALL = 25.2

Mulligan's

Mulligan's Deli

83 Canal St.

Boston, MA 02114

Presentation = 2.4

Taste = 4.8

Eatability = 3.8

Bread = 4.0

Sauce = 4.2

Cheese = 3.1

Price: $7.50

OVERALL = 22.3

Cafe Rustico

Cafe Rustico

85 Canal St.

Boston, MA 02114

Presentation = 4.1
Taste = 4.6
Eatability = 4.5
Bread = 4.9
Sauce = 3.9
Cheese = 3.4

Price: $8.50

OVERALL = 25.4